Unpaid lots, underbidders and winners who walk away
Nov 19, 2026
We recommend Option A: a line you set for each tier, tighter for Tier 1. The reserve is a hard floor; below it, the studio or consignor decides. An underbidder whose last bid sits within your line of the winning hammer price gets the offer; otherwise the lot is relisted, after at most two offers. Walking away should cost the winner more than paying, through consequences written into the buyer terms.
Agreed on 18 Nov: 14 days to pay; if unpaid, the first underbidder is offered the lot automatically with 3 days to accept; if they decline, the lot is relisted. What is open is how far below the winning bid an underbidder can be.
What you told us
"if someone ends up not paying, like three days for them to accept it is great. And then if, if they decline, then we relist it." (18 Nov)
"I mean, I think first one should be automatic" (18 Nov)
"if it's over X percentage or Y dollar amount on a rule base, then it includes or excludes the, the next bidder" (18 Nov)
"30, 40% lower or whatever ... it's probably better to rerun the auction or do something in a different format" (18 Nov)
"it kind of encourages the underbidders to keep underbidding" (18 Nov, on winners who walk away)
The underbidder rule
We recommend Option A, set in five parts:
The reserve is a hard floor. An underbidder below the reserve never gets an automatic offer; the studio or consignor decides yes or no.
The gap is measured from the winning hammer price, premium excluded, as a percentage. A dollar amount can be added as a second test for lower-value lots, as you suggested on 18 Nov.
One line per tier, set by you. Tighter for Tier 1, where price history and the studio's view matter most; looser for everyday lots, where relisting costs more next to the lot's value. The 30 to 40% you named as too wide caps the range.
At most two offers, then relist into the next suitable sale. The failed sale is kept out of price history, as Fanatics Collect does.
Review after the first sales: the gaps between winners and the next bidders, how many offers are accepted, and how relisted lots do.
The underbidder pays their own last bid plus the buyer's premium, not the winner's price, as with eBay's second-chance offers.
| Example only: winning hammer $40,000, reserve $28,000 | Underbidder's last bid | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| First underbidder, within your line | $38,000 | Offered at $38,000, 3 days to accept |
| Second underbidder, gap wider than your line | $30,000 | Relisted in the next suitable sale |
| An underbidder below the reserve | $26,000 | No automatic offer; the studio or consignor decides |
In practice the line mostly decides the second offer. With maximum bids, the winner usually pays about one bid increment above the underbidder's maximum (Heritage, Invaluable), so the first underbidder almost always sits close to the winning price. Large gaps come from a jump bid or from the second underbidder.
How it runs
The platform keeps every bidder's bids on each lot after the sale closes, including maximum bids, so the offer runs without anyone at RedBird assembling it.
After the 14 days to pay, an invoice still unpaid (above the card-only cap, or after the day-15 card charge is declined) triggers the check on the highest other bidder.
If they pass the rule, they get an offer at their own last bid, paid through the same checkout as an invoice, with 3 days to accept.
If they decline or the offer expires, the next bidder is checked; after two offers the lot is relisted.
Every step is recorded in the bidder's account history.
Before any offer, the platform checks that the underbidder is not linked to the winner who defaulted, for example the same card behind both accounts. The reserve test, the line per tier, the offer window and the number of offers are all settings RedBird can change without a new release.
What others do
No house or platform we checked publishes a gap line. Heritage keeps the right to sell to underbidders and eBay leaves the choice to the seller; the others resell at their discretion and make the defaulter pay any shortfall. A written line would be RedBird's own rule: the rule-based version of that discretion. Pages read 19 Nov 2026 unless marked.
| House | What happens to an unpaid lot |
|---|---|
| Heritage | May sell it "to any underbidders in the Auction", sell it publicly or privately, or relist it; the defaulter pays resale costs, including a 15% seller's commission, and any shortfall plus interest |
| eBay | Second Chance Offer: the seller chooses which bidders get an offer, at their own last bid, "up to 60 days after an auction ends"; only bidders who opted in |
| RR Auction | May "resell the property without reserve at public auction or privately"; the defaulter pays any deficiency and liquidated damages |
| Propstore (London sale terms) | May "resell the Lot publicly or privately on such terms as Propstore shall think fit" |
| Christie's (read 16 Nov) | Cancels and resells publicly or privately; the buyer pays the shortfall and costs |
| Phillips (read 16 Nov) | Cancels and resells; the defaulter pays the shortfall plus the seller's commission |
| Julien's (read 16 Nov) | Resells publicly or privately; recovers the deficiency, both commissions and legal fees |
| Fanatics Collect (read 16 Nov) | Relists the lot; the failed sale is kept out of sales-history comparables; no offer to underbidders |
What the rules say
We found no US law or card-network rule on second-chance offers; the protections sit in each house's terms. The points for your legal team are listed under For legal below.
Options compared
| A · A line you set per tier (recommended) | B · Always offer above the reserve | |
|---|---|---|
| For collectors | Underbidders close to the winning price get the lot; big gaps go back to open bidding | Every underbidder above the reserve gets a chance |
| For consignors and studios | Hero lots do not sell far below their result | A sale now, at or above the reserve |
| Revenue | Some lots wait for a relist | Faster sale, possibly well below the hammer price |
| Gaming risk | A winner who walks away cannot hand a linked bidder a cheap lot | Easier to game: a winner walks away and a linked underbidder takes the lot lower |
| Operations | Automatic; one setting per tier | Automatic |
| Matches what you asked on 18 Nov | Yes: rule-based, by percentage or dollar amount | No |
The case for B, and our answer. The reserve is the price the consignor already accepted, a sale now beats a relist weeks later, and the defaulter owes the difference anyway. Under A the first underbidder almost always passes the line, so A keeps that benefit and applies the line only where the gap is large, which is the case you raised.
Winners who walk away
Without consequences, underbidders learn to wait for winners to default. We recommend six, written into the buyer terms, each with a precedent:
The card on file is charged for invoices within the $10,000 card-only cap, as agreed on 18 Nov (Heritage's terms allow it; Fanatics Collect does it). When is covered in Card fees and charging the card on file.
No new bids while an invoice is overdue, and the bidding line drops to zero (eBay and Fanatics Collect restrict the account).
A default fee on a lot left unpaid, plus any shortfall when it resells (Heritage's 20% fee; RR's liquidated damages).
Future bids refused, or a deposit required (Propstore, Christie's, Phillips, Julien's). The account closes after an unpaid lot, as discussed on 18 Nov.
Legal and collection costs fall on the defaulter (Heritage, RR, Hake's).
A fresh start is hard: above the starting line every bidder has given ID or already paid, and the platform recognises the same card behind a new account.
| House | What a winner who doesn't pay faces |
|---|---|
| Heritage | May void the sale after 7 days (Select) or 14 days (Signature), or charge a 20% fee; 3% late fee and interest; the card on file may be charged; resale costs and any shortfall; attorney's fees |
| RR Auction | $45 or 2% a month late charge; interest at 1.5% a month; liquidated damages; privileges "may be revoked"; attorney's fees |
| Propstore (London sale terms) | Interest at 5% above base; future bids rejected or a deposit required |
| Phillips (read 16 Nov) | 16% a year interest; future bids barred or a cash deposit required; the buyer's name released to the seller |
| Hake's | "all bidders are obligated to honor their bids"; 1.5% a month late fee; court and attorney's fees |
| eBay | 4 days to pay; "restrictions on buying, bidding, and making offers" |
| Catawiki | Pay within 3 days, or Catawiki may suspend bidding |
How we measure it
| Proposal | What it moves | How we measure it |
|---|---|---|
| Underbidder line per tier | Unpaid lots that still sell, and at what price | Share of unpaid lots resold to an underbidder; offers accepted; resale price against the original hammer price; days from default to resale |
| Walk-away consequences | How often winners default | Unpaid lots per month, and repeat defaulters |
We report these after every sale and review the line with you after the first sales; you set the targets.
For legal
Consignment wording that lets RedBird sell to an underbidder at or above the reserve without asking the studio or consignor each time.
Offer wording that makes clear the underbidder pays their own bid plus the buyer's premium.
The default fee and shortfall recovery in RedBird's buyer terms, against the levels Heritage and RR use.
What we need from you
The line per tier: how far below the winning hammer price an underbidder may be, tighter for Tier 1.
A dollar test: whether one applies too, for lower-value lots.
Below the reserve: who at the studio or consignor says yes or no, and how fast.
The default fee: whether RedBird charges one, and at what level.
Povio builds the day-15 check, the offers, the link check between bidders and the settings in the admin.
Sources
Read 16 to 19 Nov 2026, as marked. Your words are from our call on 18 Nov.
Heritage Auctions, Terms and Conditions of Auction (rev. 8 Apr 2025), paragraphs 26, 29, 30 and 31. Read 19 Nov.
Heritage Auctions, Web tips. Read 16 Nov.
eBay, Making Second Chance Offers. Read 19 Nov.
eBay, Unpaid item policy. Read 19 Nov.
RR Auction, Terms and Conditions, sections 2.3, 6, 12 and 20.7. Read 19 Nov.
Propstore, Live Auction Catalogue terms (London sale), conditions 7.11 and 7.12. Read 19 Nov.
Hake's, Terms and Conditions. Read 19 Nov.
Christie's, Conditions of Sale, New York (12 Aug 2024). Read 16 Nov.
Phillips, Conditions of Sale, New York. Read 16 Nov.
Julien's Auctions, Terms and Conditions. Read 16 Nov.
Fanatics Collect, FAQ. Read 16 Nov.
Invaluable, Bidding FAQ. Read 16 Nov.
Catawiki, Buyer Terms (valid from 15 Sep 2026). Read 17–18 Nov.